The morning after fucking Harvey for the first time, Sabrina comes into the kitchen to her step-Aunt Zelda and step-Aunt Hilda implying that they know. Once her aunts leave, Sabrina confesses to Salem that she thinks she came on too strong. Salem suggests a spell and Sabrina agrees. She's just finishing up with that when Zelda returns to the kitchen and suggests that maybe they should cancel their plans and invite Harvey over instead. Sabrina agrees.

While the girls wait for Harvey, Zelda decides to get ready by magicking herself into some lingerie. Sabrina matches suit, claiming that Harvey is hers. When Harvey finally arrives, Zelda can't keep her hands off of him. Although Sabrina and Harvey are confused, they let Zelda join in on the fun. Soon both girls are on their knees sucking Harvey's cock. Then they magic themselves out of their clothes so that Sabrina can ride Harvey's mouth while Zelda rides his dick.

Switching things up, Zelda takes Sabrina in her arms to fondle her nubile titties as Harvey feasts on Sabrina's pussy. Then Sabrina finally gets her boyfriend's D back inside her as she eats Zelda out while Harvey bangs her from behind. Zelda gets another go on Harvey's fuck stick before both girls kneel with their backs to Harvey so he can work them each to a final climax and cum on their back. The threesome is just winding down when Hilda arrives and tells Sabrina that she has put a love spell on Zelda.